Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar in Peabody

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar in Peabody
4 / 5
50 reviews

203 Newbury St, Peabody, MA 01960-2411, Peabody

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Seafood

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Is it still open for business?

Yes, its freshly painted, prices raised, but still good

When is Sea Witch closing

It's not, no owner leased it out for 20 yrs

All the questions are old, so are they opened?? If so what are the hours during the week and weekends??

They'll be closed tonight and tomorrow

There is no website to check menus & prices?

The food quality is very very good atmosphere very casual nothing fancy at all

Do u off a senior discount we r going tomorrow and I can’t wait

Sorry I can't say for sure, but I think so!

Do they offer mussels

Yes

hi can i have oyster

I'm not sure, you'd have to call and see if they have them on the menu today.

Do you serve fried lobster ?

Yes

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
JT
Joseph Tavano
google
11.21.2024
5/5

Original staff and owners are back, and this place is a perennial institution. One of the best places in New England to get fish. Order anything you want it's all delicious. And bring cash to tip your waitstaff!

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
CB
Chuck Binda
google
11.14.2018
4/5

Food was very good had the scallops and my wife had the lobster roll. It was a little thrown off by order at the counter and then they brought it to you. Place is very clean. Staff very nice.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
RE
Rhonda E Smith-Phipps
google
10.02.2018
5/5

Food was great. Not to long of a wait place your order pick it up when its ready.. prices not to bad

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
GB
Gwen Brounce
google
08.18.2018
5/5

The best lobster rolls, delicious Chardonnay and a great New England atmosphere/decor. Visiting with a friend who took me there. Clean restrooms and friendly staff. A fresh seafood market adjoins the restaurant. Went for lunch - would highly recommend SeaGrilz!

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
CG
Charles Gardella
google
06.22.2018
3/5

Is there some reason you don't offer salmon dinners? Your chowders are excellent as other items on the menu! Too bad no salmon or cod filet!

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
BS
Behnam Sadeghi
google
05.16.2018
5/5

The restaurant is not fancy, but the food is. My lobster was fresh and delicious. My waitress was excellent.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
YB
Yessenia Baez
google
05.11.2018
5/5

The seafood is fresh service is great, indoors or outdoors. Love it

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
FM
Florence Marcotullio
google
04.07.2018
5/5

T enjoy the restaurant food was fresh and service good we will be going back.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
CB
Cheryl Bento
google
03.07.2018
5/5

Awesome seafood! Food is fresh, never greasy! You get alot for your money. Never disappointed! Clean restaurant. Staff is friendly . Cassie is the best. She gives excellent service! Seafood market next door. Plenty of parking . Easy in & out access to Rte. 1. Variety of bottled beer & wine. Beer on tap. I always enjoy sitting at the bar & enjoy conversation with Cassie & Angelo( the owner) I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for excellent Seafood.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
Brennon
google
02.01.2018
4/5

cool little spot to eat. Great market to buy fresh fish.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
ds
donald smith
google
01.25.2018
5/5

Great food, great folks. An awesome combination. Hadnt been there since i was a kid but will b going back regularly now.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
LF
Lynne Fitzpatrick
google
01.20.2018
5/5

Great food and great service. Affordable prices...

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
CK
Carson Kolberg
google
01.16.2018
5/5

Destination restaurant for top notch seafood selection at reasonable prices.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
PF
Page Ford
google
11.19.2017
5/5

First time there....fresh meals and delicious!

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
JL
John La Corte
google
10.23.2017
5/5

Great seafood and very reasonably priced. Waitress was great too.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
bb
billy baru
google
10.16.2017
2/5

Just purchased a broiled fisherman's platter and it was not bad. From a 1-10 maybe a 7 but lobster stew was horrible. Taste like they were running out and added water to top it off. Absolutely no taste whatsoever. Oh and not 1 piece of lobster. Went here before and it was really good so I came back and this is what I get. Never again

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
MJ
Matthew Johnson SEO
google
10.15.2017
5/5

Went here with my family. The haddock was fantastic and the service was great. You have to order and pay up front first.. then they bring you your drinks and food. Looking forward to coming back...

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
NB
Nicole B
google
07.21.2017
5/5

This place is AMAZING! We were on vacation and wanting seafood. We googled the area and came upon this place. What a treasure we found! The seafood was incredibly fresh and delicious, and the portion sizes were huge! The staff was so friendly and helpful. Could not recommend more!

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
DO
Dean Osmani
google
07.12.2017
5/5

Just phenomenal. George glad you back keep the prices low we will back until we die.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
KR
Kelley Racki-Mahan
google
06.05.2017
1/5

Food is missing every time we order!

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
TP
Terrance Pusateri
google
05.25.2017
5/5

I think this was the third time I ever had Lobster and the first having a Lobster Roll. Oh wow... Let me just say that it was super delicious! The clam chowder was off the hook too. Makes me wish I would have had a whole lobster and try every other item on the menu. I'll definitely stop here again next time I stay in Peabody.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
JB
Jesse Brooks
google
05.20.2017
4/5

Fresh seafood and friendly service!

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
BW
BONNIE WAGNER
google
04.22.2017
5/5

Every item of food is great! The seafood and no sand steam clams are the best in the area!Pleasant staff and quick cooking!

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
ZS
Zachary Smith
google
04.01.2017
5/5

Amazing lobster rolls and oysters. Will absolutely return next time I'm in the area.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
WH
Wendy Hartmann
google
03.20.2017
5/5

Always loved this place!! So glad original owners are back!! Greatest seafood on the North Shore!!

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
JT
Jen Taylor Scheetz
google
03.16.2017
4/5

Great seafood...walk in menus on the back board, specials on the chalkboard. After you order, pay at the register, then have seat. They bring the food to your table. Everything is delicious. Good serving size of sides. On my second visit I ordered a 1lb Whole steamed lobster to go with a cup of New England clam chowder. While chatting, I shared I was going back to the hotel I was staying at. To my pleasant surprise, I opened the container to find the lobster cracked so the meat just came right out! What an excellent example of anticipating the customer's needs. Service and food excellent! Must stop on my next visit to the area. (Casual attire, quick turn in from the main road, ample parking)

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
MW
Marlina Wicketts
google
02.16.2017
5/5

Visiting from the southwest and couldn't ask for better service. The owners are very kind as are all the other staff. They took the time to show us how to eat the lobster and orders we ordered as we are rookies. The food was absolutely fresh and delicious and the service couldn't have been better. Highly recommend to anyone in the area !

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
JD
JDiaz Diaz
google
02.06.2017
5/5

Food its really good i will defenlly go back

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
CJ
Chef Jonil
google
02.02.2017
5/5

I made a Lobster Spanish Omelet/Tortilla with fresh lobster from SeaWitch Fish Market. They’ve got great prices, seafood is fresh and the market is clean!

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
BC
Baez CJ
google
01.25.2017
5/5

Wow this place is so good. I will definitely come back. Seafood is fresh

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
JB
Joyce Bassett
google
01.17.2017
5/5

Delicious food friendly staff easy access no stairs

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
sK
sarah Keenan
google
01.13.2017
5/5

I've been here 3 times, always amazing. The clam and scallop plate is huge and the food is fantastic.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
LC
Leda Coco
google
01.03.2017
5/5

By far the best fish batter: delicate with a hidden hint of flavor that set it apart. The fried coconut shrimp app. was addictive and more than enough for the three of us. One diner had the fillet of sole that just melted in her mouth. Another diner said the scallops were very tender and not fish bland. The batter for the onion rings was not heavy and thick, said one of the diners, and the cole slaw was just right, not overly tangy. Good fish food experience.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
MJ
Margie J. Sands
google
11.15.2016
5/5

First time I've eaten there, it was really good, and they give you big Portions. It's not expensive either! We will be going back there soon!!

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
JC
Julie Campos
google
11.13.2016
5/5

Food and service were excellent, wish we lived closer we would be back often.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
rl
ray lawton
google
11.08.2016
5/5

This is the best place for Salmon around. Prices are very reasonable

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
AH
Andy Harris
google
10.21.2016
5/5

Amazing lobster rolls, excellent friendly service!

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
AM
Amber M. Keating
google
09.27.2016
5/5

While the current listing says "SeaGrilz," the restaurant has transferred back to its original owner and name: SeaWitch. This is a famous staple in the area, well known for their incredible seafood. The batter they use is perfect, light and flavorful. They also have their own root beer and cream soda, which are delicious! I'm a big fan of these Lobster Pie, Clam Chowder, Fish & Chips, and Fried Scallops, as well as their Onion Rings. The fries that come with the entrees are thick-cut steak fries. My family also had some dessert this trip: Rice Pudding and Grapenut Pudding. I had never heard of the latter before, but I guess it's a New England thing! I had a bite of the Rice Pudding (too full of seafood to have my own!) and it was delicious. I strongly recommend SeaWitch if you're looking for great seafood in a low key environment.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
CH
Clayton Heywood
google
08.22.2016
4/5

Steamed lobsters were excellent and priced well. Other seafood others are a bit pricey!

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
MW
MAUREEN Whitcomb
google
08.04.2016
5/5

Old owners are here. Very good food. They take credit cards.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
RD
Randy Dublo
google
07.25.2016
5/5

Fresh, delicious, generous portions and great service.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
s!
scott !
google
07.21.2016
4/5

It was actually really good. When I went in, I thought that the prices were kind of high but you definitely get your monies worth.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
SS
Samantha Schena
google
06.26.2016
5/5

Lovely staff and food was wonderful

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
MG
MKFM Gaming
google
06.04.2016
2/5

I asked for some slices of fruit, I understand it’s definitely an odd request but the slices of orange had mold. There were quite a few flies on the window, three of them. So I looked down into the window and there were so many dead bugs. The $1 oysters were good but now I'm worried about the sanitary conditions. The food came out quick and all the other tables seemed to get very good looking food so I don't think the quality of the food is bad by no means. Very friendly people they just need to take a day and deep clean the restaurant!

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
DG
Donald Gray
google
05.14.2016
1/5

I don't usually write reviews but the mediocrity of this place stands out. Today was my second time there. The first time it was just okay and I never should have gone back but a friend wanted to go there. I ordered the clam chowder because I really like clam chowder and the reviews were good. It was the worst clam chowder that I can recall eating. NO CLAMS! I should have sent it back and I'm sure they would have offered to bring me something else but I wasn't willing to wait for another mediocre dish.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
JD
Ju Dommy
google
03.23.2016
4/5

Very good food. Raving about their clam chowder. You pay first then sit to eat. Lobster roll was pretty good and gave a lot for it's price. Definitely would return

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
RM
Ray Marchetti
google
03.21.2016
5/5

Great food better than belle isle

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
RS
Rob Solomon
google
03.19.2016
4/5

The food was delicious but the price has increased since it changed hands. There used to be good lunch specials, but they’re gone now so the prices start at about $15. Ok for a special event but too much for just “Tuesday” lunch, you know? But the food and service are still good. They have a tent out front for beer and boiled lobsters and clams... it looks like fun on the right day.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
CC
Christopher Carey
google
02.01.2016
5/5

Great restaurant. Choose and pay at the counter. Find a seat and they bring your food to you. I liked everything I tried. The clam chowder and lobster pie were excellent. The staff is second to none.

Sea Witch Restaurant & Oyster Bar
MC
Michael C.
google
01.18.2016
1/5

Terrible place. Fish chowder was a big bowl of snot with a thin slice of fish floating on top. I immediately knew I wasn't going to eat it based on looks alone. But I paid for it so a small taste was necessary. Flavorless with a disgusting texture, I wouldn't feed it to street dog. It was without a doubt the worst food I ever ordered in my life. At least the waitress refunded my money.Don't waste your time or money at this dump. Go to Ipswich or Essex.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 19785356057

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!